Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts

the 21st century education

Since I was in college, I've been frustrated with the way the modern academic system works. Over time, that dissatisfaction has only grown more severe. As a value investor, my goal is to get the most value for the price paid. Yet formal education is an investment whose value seems to have decreased over time - it provides less and costs more every year. At my alma mater, students today are paying more than double the tuition I did to receive an education that is a commodity. I believe there are much better ways to deliver education that don't involve formal education or degrees, but rather systems that potential employers agree offer a comprehensive assessment of skills. In short, it'd be a, "I don't care how you learned it if you know it" approach. Folks with the wherewithal to learn the requisite skills through self- or small-group study would be encouraged to do so. Others could pursue a more formal path but not by following the pre-determined, formal curriculum that now exists.

One university is taking some concrete steps to shift the model, and it sounds promising. Steve Blank wrote a nice blog entry about it. It's available here.


An Educational Bargain?

Was the slamming of Apollo Education (APOL) shares yesterday an overreaction? The sharp (22%) drop had to do with below-expectation earnings growth and the fact that numbers might have to be restated once the company has completed its review of options practices. The million-dollar question – what impact will restatements, if any, have on the financial statements?

The company operates the largest private university in the country (University of Phoenix) and offers educational programs and services at 100 campuses and 159 learning centers in 39 states, Puerto Rico, Washington DC, Alberta, British Columbia, Netherlands, and Mexico. Management controls the company, as the founder and his son own all of the voting shares. This can be good and bad, but overall you can bet they're watching out for company interests and not taking undue risks with the capital that represents a significant portion of their net worth. The company carries no debt and its returns on capital have averaged in the high 20s over the past 10 years (over 40s in the last couple). Of course, restatements may affect the return on capital numbers, but not the fact that they carry no debt on the balance sheet (though there are about $120M of operating leases off-balance sheet).


Upon cursory examination, this looks like a good value at 13 times forward earnings and a free cash flow yield of 8.3%. They’ve been using that discretionary cash to buy back shares the last several years, which has more than offset the dilution from option exercises. With the growth opportunities that lie ahead, this could be a screaming bargain. But how reliable are the numbers? I’ll post more thoughts later.