Showing posts with label Philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Philosophy. Show all posts

Ability to Pass Up Investments is Key

As Warren Buffett has said, the ability to say “No” is one of the most important powers an investor has. Knowing when to turn down an investment can be more important as when to say yes. Another way I’ve heard Buffett look at it is to imagine as an investor that you’ve got a 20-slot punch card that represents your lifetime of investment decisions to be made. Looking at it from this perspective, it’s likely each investment decision will be made more carefully.

Another crucial part of making good investment decisions is being aware of your own biases. These biases are well-documented in behavioral finance: overconfidence, hindsight bias, overreaction, belief perseverance, and regret avoidance, for example. Knowing where you decisions are coming from helps to determine whether your choices are truly objective and rational, not overly influenced by your own biases.

Companies Should be Viewed As Investment Conduits

We think that the best way to view a company is as an investment vehicle. This is what corporate management is paid to do – invest shareholder capital in areas where attractive investment returns are (hopefully) available.

At its base, a business invests capital in a collection of projects, products, or services and hopes to earn a return commensurate with the risk taken. It wants to earn a return on its invested capital – that is, equity and debt invested. And over time, the business will create wealth if it can earn above its cost of capital.

For a simple example, we’ll ignore taxes and consider a piece of real estate worth $1 million. Perhaps the buyer puts down 20% ($200k) of the purchase price, leaving $800k to be financed with debt at an 8% interest rate. So, the debt portion must earn enough in rent to pay costs plus an 8% (net of tax) payment to at least break even. That is, costs (maintenance, management, insurance, taxes, etc.) plus $64,000 to pay the principal and interest (P&I) on the loan. This is break-even on the debt portion.

The equity (20%) portion is a little trickier since it doesn’t actually have an explicit cost. Yet according to economic theory, this portion should be assigned an opportunity cost. For example, the opportunity forgone to invest in a similarly risky stock or bond that would earn 10%. Thus, this portion should earn costs plus 10% to earn an economically break-even return – $20,000 after costs.

In order to earn an excess economic return, returns must be greater than the weighted-average of these capital costs – [(.20x10%)+(.80x8%] = 8.4% after costs to break even in economic terms. So if the investment earns 10%, there is a 1.6% excess return (10%-8.4%). This is how economic wealth is created.

Many companies do not earn long run returns above their cost of capital, so how do they go on living? Certainly if it can’t pay its debts it should be bankrupt! Well, as I mentioned, the equity portion of capital does not really have an explicit cost, so a company can still cover its explicit debt costs while eroding the returns to equity.

Same thing in the real estate example. If it only earns 7% on the entire building after costs, it still has $70,000 to cover the $64,000 P&I. Ignoring principal payoff and appreciation, this leaves only $6,000 for the equity portion – a 3% return on the equity. If such a situation is expected to continue, this capital would be better employed in a money market account earning 5%. The exact same concept applies to publicly traded companies, albeit on a more complicated scale.

The bottom line is that we want a company to, say, borrow at 7% what it can invest at 15%, earning the “spread” of the investment return minus its cost of capital. This is, at its base, what every company is trying to do whether it sells steel, toilet paper, tax preparation, or owns real estate. Earning a return on its investments above the cost of the funds in the long run generates economic value for shareholders.

A Few Words on Our Investment Philosophy

A few words about the investment philosophy that is behind the postings on this site:

In most cases, we’re trying to determine what the value of a company is to a private market buyer in a negotiated transaction. But we’re not going to pay that price. We want to buy the company at a (hopefully large) discount from this value. After all, as a minority shareholder, we can’t have any influence on what the company does with its excess cash flows. That is, the cash beyond what is needed to sustain and grow the business given available reinvestment or new investment opportunities. A private market buyer would be able to go in and, say, invest in public securities or pay out the excess cash to himself. And thus he should have to pay more for this control. Sometimes, we can profit from this difference between our position and his. We look at adjusted book values, normal earning power, free cash flow generation, and other metrics to determine what a company is worth.

As Charlie Munger has said, “It’s not a competency unless you know the edge of it.” We can’t know everything, but we try to be aware of what we don't know. We look for businesses we understand that are being run by honest, able managers whose personal stakes in the success of the company are high. If we can buy these companies below what they are worth, we should do reasonably well over the long-term.

We’re not worried about near-term market prices, just investment risk – something going wrong with the business. If we find value, we feel comfortable making a purchase and waiting for the market price to take care of itself. If the company’s management continues to create value by generating satisfactory incremental investment returns, the market price should rise accordingly, albeit non-linearly with intrinsic value. This is not to say that we aren’t concerned with market prices, we are just not focused solely on them.

Also, some ideas posted here are not meant to be long-term. These could be called “trades.” But such trades are taken with a long-term perspective.